Pickles and Relishes
Vinegar pickles and relishes are safe for the boiling-water bath because the vinegar makes them acidic, which is also why the proportions in a tested recipe must not change.
- Difficulty
- Easy
- Time
- An afternoon
- Cost
- $20–$50 a batch
- Season
- July through September
Why pickles are safe in a water bath
Cucumbers, peppers, onions and beans are low-acid vegetables. On their own they need a pressure canner. Pickling makes them safe for the boiling-water bath by adding enough vinegar to bring the whole jar below the pH where botulism can grow. The tested recipe works out how much vinegar is needed for a given amount of vegetables, so the ratio of vinegar to water to vegetables is the part you must not change.
Use vinegar labeled 5 percent acidity. Homemade vinegar and some specialty vinegars vary, so save them for the table. If a brine tastes too sharp, add sugar rather than cutting the vinegar or adding water.
Ingredients that make a difference
Pickling cucumbers are short, bumpy and thin-skinned. Salad cucumbers turn soft. Pick them small and pickle within 24 hours; if you must hold them, keep them cool. Cut off a sixteenth of an inch from the blossom end, which holds enzymes that soften pickles.
Use canning or pickling salt. Table salt contains anti-caking agents that cloud the brine, and iodine can darken the pickles. Use fresh whole spices for clear brine. Soft water gives the best results; very hard water can leave white sediment, and many Front Range taps run hard. Boiling hard water and letting it settle, or using distilled water, helps.
Making a batch of dill spears
Follow your tested recipe for the brine, packing and processing time. The steps look like this.
- Wash the cucumbers in cold water, scrubbing off the spines, and trim the blossom ends.
- Cut into spears or slices as the recipe directs. Chill them in ice water for a few hours if you like crisper pickles.
- Heat the canner water and keep the jars hot.
- Bring the vinegar, water and salt to a boil.
- Put dill and spices in each jar, pack the cucumbers firmly without crushing them, and pour the hot brine over, leaving the headspace the recipe gives.
- Remove air bubbles, wipe rims, and add lids and bands.
- Process in the water bath for the recipe time plus your altitude addition: 10 minutes more between 3,001 and 6,000 feet, 15 minutes more between 6,001 and 8,000 feet, unless the recipe gives its own table.
- Let the jars sit for at least three weeks before opening so the flavor develops.
Relishes and other vegetables
Relishes are chopped vegetables cooked in a vinegar syrup. Because chopped vegetables pack densely, relish recipes have their own processing times; do not borrow them from a spear recipe. The same goes for pickled beets, peppers, green beans and carrots, each tested separately. Pickled peppers need a recipe that matches the amount of pepper to the vinegar, and hot peppers call for gloves.
Refrigerator pickles skip processing and are kept in the refrigerator, usually for a few weeks to a couple of months depending on the recipe. Fermented pickles are a different method that relies on salt and lactic acid, much like fermenting sauerkraut.
Crispness
Older recipes used alum or slaked lime to crisp pickles. Alum does not help much with modern methods, and lime must be rinsed out completely because it reduces acidity. Fresh cucumbers, trimmed ends and a cold soak do most of the work, and so does a processing time that is not stretched beyond what the recipe and your altitude call for, since extra minutes in the bath cook the pickles soft. Calcium chloride products sold for pickling can be added as the label directs. Grow your own cucumbers alongside the dill and other herbs, or pick them up at farmers markets the morning you plan to pickle.
| Problem | Likely cause | Fix |
|---|---|---|
| Pickles are soft or slippery | Blossom ends not trimmed, too little vinegar, or old cucumbers | Trim ends, use fresh cucumbers and keep the tested vinegar ratio; discard slippery pickles |
| Brine is cloudy | Table salt, hard water, or spoilage | Use pickling salt and soft water; if the jar smells off or the lid bulges, discard it |
| Pickles are hollow | Cucumbers held too long after picking | Pickle within 24 hours of harvest |
Reviewed November 2026.
Read next
- PantryWater-Bath Canning Basics
Boiling-water canning is the simplest way to put up jams, pickles and acidified tomatoes, and at Front Range elevations it needs a little more time than the recipe card shows.
- PantryFermenting Sauerkraut
Sauerkraut is cabbage, salt and time, and getting the salt ratio and temperature right is what keeps the fermentation safe and the kraut crisp.
- PantryCanning at High Altitude
Water boils at about 202 degrees in Denver instead of 212, and every canning recipe has to make up for that lost heat with extra time or extra pressure.