Skip to the page
Austin's Homestead

Growing, raising and putting up food on Colorado's Front Range

Pantry

Making Butter and Soft Cheese

Butter and fresh soft cheese are the easiest dairy projects for a home kitchen, and clean handling, good milk and cold storage are what keep them safe.

Difficulty
Easy
Time
An hour or two
Cost
$10–$40 a batch
Season
Year-round, best in spring

How butter and fresh cheese form

Butter is cream agitated until its fat globules break open and clump together, leaving buttermilk behind. Fresh soft cheese is milk whose proteins are made to clump into curds, either with acid and heat or with a culture and rennet. Both are old, simple processes, but they work with a food that spoils easily, so the method is mostly about cleanliness and cold.

A quart of heavy cream yields roughly a pound of butter and a pint or so of buttermilk. A gallon of whole milk gives about a pound and a half to two pounds of acid-set cheese, depending on how long you drain it. These are small projects that fit into an evening and use little equipment beyond what most kitchens already have.

Safety in general terms

Start with clean, sanitized equipment and wash your hands well. Use pasteurized milk and cream for these projects; it is the safest choice for beginners. Raw milk can carry harmful bacteria. Keep finished butter and cheese refrigerated, use fresh cheese within about a week, and throw out anything that smells sour in the wrong way, turns slimy or grows mold. People who are pregnant, elderly or have weak immune systems should be especially careful with soft cheeses.

Churning butter

  1. Let heavy cream sit until it is about 55 to 60 degrees; very cold cream takes longer to churn and warm cream turns greasy.
  2. Pour it into a stand mixer, food processor or jar no more than half full.
  3. Beat or shake. The cream will thicken into whipped cream, stiffen, then suddenly break into yellow grains of butter and thin buttermilk.
  4. Pour off the buttermilk and save it for baking.
  5. Rinse the butter in very cold water, pressing and kneading it, and change the water until it runs clear. Leftover buttermilk is what makes butter go sour quickly.
  6. Press out as much water as you can, then work in salt if you like.
  7. Shape, wrap and refrigerate. It keeps for a couple of weeks in the refrigerator or several months frozen.

An acid-set soft cheese

The simplest cheeses use only milk, heat and acid. For a ricotta-style cheese or paneer, heat whole milk slowly in a heavy pot, stirring so it does not scorch, until it is just below a simmer, around 185 to 195 degrees. Turn off the heat and stir in lemon juice, vinegar or a citric acid solution a little at a time until the curds separate from a yellow-green whey. Let it rest for a few minutes, then ladle the curds into a cheesecloth-lined colander. Drain briefly for soft ricotta-style cheese. For paneer, gather the cloth and press the curds under a weight for an hour to make a firm block that holds its shape when cooked.

Cultured soft cheeses

Cheeses such as chevre-style goat cheese, cream cheese and queso fresco use a starter culture and a small amount of rennet. They take longer and need steady temperatures, so follow a tested recipe and buy cultures from a cheesemaking supplier. Ultra-pasteurized milk is heated so much that it often will not form a firm curd with rennet; regular pasteurized milk works better.

A home dairy animal changes the scale of all this. If you are considering one, read dairy goats for beginners first. Whey from cheesemaking can be used in bread dough or fed in modest amounts to pigs.

When it goes wrong
ProblemLikely causeFix
Cream will not turn to butterCream too cold or too warm, or a low-fat creamBring it to 55 to 60 degrees and use heavy cream
Butter turns sour within daysButtermilk left in the butterRinse in cold water until it runs clear and press it well
Milk will not curdle for cheeseUltra-pasteurized milk or not enough heat or acidUse regular pasteurized milk, check the temperature and add acid gradually

Reviewed November 2026.

Read next

  • Animals
    Dairy Goats for Beginners

    Dairy goats can supply a household with milk from a small acreage, but they need company, strong fences and a twice-daily routine that doesn't take holidays.

  • Pantry
    Sourdough at Altitude

    Lower air pressure and dry air change how sourdough behaves above 5,000 feet, and a few adjustments to water, proofing and baking bring the loaf back in line.

  • Pantry
    A Year of Pantry Planning

    A good pantry starts with what your household eats in a year, then matches each food to the preservation method and the season that suit it best.