Skip to the page
Austin's Homestead

Growing, raising and putting up food on Colorado's Front Range

Animals

Hay and Feed Buying Guide

Hay is the largest winter expense for most small livestock keepers, and knowing what to buy, when and how to store it saves money and keeps animals healthy.

Difficulty
Easy
Time
An afternoon per purchase
Cost
$10–$25 per small bale
Season
Summer for hay, year-round for feed

Why hay matters

For goats, sheep, horses, cattle and rabbits, hay is the base of the diet for much of the year. Poor hay leads to poor condition, digestive problems and higher feed bills, since animals waste more and need more supplements. Good hay supports healthy animals at lower overall cost. On the Front Range, where winter grazing is thin, most small herds rely on hay from November to April or longer.

Types of hay

  • Grass hay such as brome, orchard grass and timothy is lower in protein and calcium. It suits horses, idle goats and sheep, wethers and rabbits.
  • Alfalfa is rich in protein and calcium. It suits does in milk, growing kids and lambs, and hard-working animals, but too much can cause digestive upsets or contribute to urinary stones in wethers.
  • Grass and alfalfa mixes balance the two and are a common choice for mixed herds.
  • Cuttings. Irrigated fields along the Front Range are often cut two to four times a season. First cutting is often coarser and stemmier; later cuttings are usually finer and leafier.

Our guides to dairy goats and keeping goats healthy explain how hay fits each animal's needs.

Judging quality

Open a bale before you buy. Good hay smells sweet, is green rather than brown or bleached, is leafy, and is free of mold, dust, weeds and trash. Look for:

  • White or gray patches, a musty smell or heavy dust, which signal mold
  • Thick, woody stems and few leaves, which mean it was cut late
  • Weeds such as foxtail, which can injure mouths, or toxic plants
  • Blister beetles in alfalfa, which can be deadly to horses; ask the grower about their practices
  • Bales that feel heavy, damp or warm, which suggest moisture

Ask for a forage test if you buy a lot of hay. CSU Extension can explain how to sample and interpret results.

Buying steps

  1. Estimate how much each animal eats per day, roughly 2 to 3 percent of body weight in hay for many grazing animals, and multiply by the days in your feeding season.
  2. Add 10 to 20 percent for waste and late spring storms.
  3. Find growers through neighbors, the county extension office, feed stores and local farm listings in early summer.
  4. Ask about the field, cutting, bale weight and how the hay was stored.
  5. Open a bale or two before buying, and buy the whole winter supply from one lot when possible, so quality is consistent.
  6. Weigh a few bales. Small square bales commonly run about 50 to 70 pounds, and price per ton is the fairest comparison.
  7. Arrange delivery, or plan several trips with a truck or trailer you can load safely.

Storage and fire safety

Store hay off the ground on pallets, under a roof or a tarp that sheds rain and snow, with airflow. Hay baled too wet can heat as it cures and, in rare cases, catch fire. For the first few weeks after a new delivery, check the inside of stacks for warmth. If bales are hot, separate them and call your fire department if they are very hot or smoking. Keep hay storage away from your house and away from electrical equipment.

Grain, pellets and minerals

Buy feed in amounts you can use within a couple of months, since it goes stale and attracts rodents. Store it in metal cans with tight lids. Choose rations made for each species: layer feed for hens, goat feed with appropriate minerals for goats and pellets formulated for raising rabbits. Don't let animals reach feed meant for other species, since some minerals and medications that are safe for one are harmful to another.

When it goes wrong
ProblemLikely causeFix
Moldy, dusty balesHay baled or stored too wetReturn or discard; don't feed moldy hay, especially to horses and goats
Bales warm or steaming in storageWet hay heating; a fire riskCheck temperature, spread hot bales out, and call the fire department if very hot
Running out of hay in MarchUnderestimating winter needsCalculate needs in summer and buy all of it before fall

Reviewed November 2026.

Read next

  • Animals
    Dairy Goats for Beginners

    Dairy goats can supply a household with milk from a small acreage, but they need company, strong fences and a twice-daily routine that doesn't take holidays.

  • Animals
    Keeping Goats Healthy

    Most goat health comes down to good hay, clean water, the right minerals and noticing early when an animal is off, then calling a vet who knows goats.

  • Animals
    Raising Rabbits

    Rabbits are quiet, efficient and fit small spaces, but on the Front Range they need protection from summer heat as much as from winter cold.